Analyzing the Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5

Analyzing the Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5

Animal Farm by George Orwell is a classic novel that has been studied and analyzed for decades. One of the most pivotal and intriguing chapters of the book is Chapter 5, where the Commandment No animal shall drink alcohol is broken. This event highlights the complexity and nuances of the animals’ new society and raises important questions about power and leadership.At the start of the chapter, readers are immediately drawn in as they witness the celebration of the animals’ victory over their human oppressors. The excitement and sense of camaraderie among the animals is infectious and inspiring. However, as the night wears on and the revelry continues, things take a dark turn.The first hint that something is amiss comes when the pigs, who have taken on positions of leadership, are seen drinking alcohol. This goes against one of the founding principles of Animalism and is a clear breach of the animals’ trust. What follows is a fascinating exploration of power dynamics and the corrupting influence of authority.As the pigs become more and more drunk, they begin to act out of control and assert their dominance over the other animals. The fact that they are breaking their own rules and indulging in behavior that they previously deemed unacceptable highlights the hypocrisy and self-serving nature of those in power. This is a warning sign of what is to come and a reminder that those with authority are not always acting in the best interests of those they lead.In conclusion, the Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5 is a pivotal moment in the book that offers a wealth of insights into the nature of power and leadership. Through analyzing this event, readers gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of the animals’ new society and the challenges that they must overcome. It is a testament to George Orwell’s skill as a writer that he is able to create such a thought-provoking and engaging narrative that continues to captivate readers today.

What Commandment Is Broken In Chapter 5 Of Animal Farm
“What Commandment Is Broken In Chapter 5 Of Animal Farm” ~ bbaz


Animal Farm, a novel written by George Orwell, is a story about animals taking control of a farm from their human owner. The animals create their own set of rules known as the “Seven Commandments,” which they vow to follow. However, as time goes on, the pigs who are the leaders of the animal community break these commandments for their own benefit. In chapter 5, we see the first of these broken commandments. In this blog post, we will analyze and compare the events leading up to the breaking of the commandment, what the broken commandment entails, and the reactions of the other animals.

Comparing the Events

The Passing of Snowball’s Windmill

In Chapter 5, Snowball proposes the idea of building a windmill to generate electricity and improve the lives of the animals. Initially, Napoleon opposes the idea and physically prevents Snowball from explaining its technicalities. After Snowball leaves the farm, Napoleon secretly summons a pack of dogs he had trained to carry out his orders and has them chase Snowball out of the territory. The animals remain divided; some support Snowball, while others believe that Napoleon is the rightful leader.

Construction of the Windmill

After Snowball’s expulsion, Napoleon takes credit for the idea and grants permission for the construction of the windmill to start. He makes promises about how much better life will be with the windmill, thus increasing his popularity amongst the animals. The animals work hard to build the windmill but struggle due to harsh weather conditions and weak resources.

Analyzing the Broken Commandment

The Commandment

The fourth commandment, No animal shall sleep in a bed was broken when Squealer justifies Napoleon’s use of a bed for his own personal comfort. He claimed that the rule only applied to the beds in the main house and that Napoleon’s bed is considered a hospital for him to recover from his “illnesses”. Thus, what was once a simple, fair-minded rule has been twisted by the pigs into “doublethink”.

Impact on the Animals

The animals are shocked and confused by the breaking of the commandment. They look back at their copies of the seven commandments which were inscribed on a barn wall, only to realize that the words have been altered to say No animal shall sleep in a bed with sheets, thus showing how the pigs twist reality to fit their requirements. One animal notes, That is the true spirit of Animalism reveals their realization of the corruption among the pigs.

Comparison Table

Chapter 5 Events Leading up to the Breaking of the Commandment Breaking of the Commandment Impact on the Animals
The Passing of Snowball’s Windmill Napoleon opposes and secretly schemes against Snowball’s idea while keeping quiet about his opposition to please the majority of the animals Squealer justifies Napoleon’s use of a bed by claiming it is used for medical purposes, thus altering the meaning of the fourth commandment The animals become suspicious and weary as they realize the pigs’ corruption
Construction of the Windmill Popularity and support of Napoleon grows as he takes credit and makes false promises None None


Orwell’s Animal Farm effectively portrays how propaganda can be used to manipulate people, into thinking and believing what those in power want them to believe, rather than confronting the truth. Furthermore, it also shows that some people are so determined to have control and power over others that they are willing to break the rules and norms they claim to follow. The fifth chapter sets a precedent for the rest of the novel, which ultimately shapes its central message against totalitarianism. Orwell demonstrates that in corrupt leaders’ hands, even a system aimed at democracy and fairness can become perverted, leading the way to a terrifying dystopian world.

We hope that you found our analysis of the Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5 informative and thought-provoking. As George Orwell’s classic novella continues to resonate with readers around the world, it is important to remember the significance of this pivotal moment in the story.

The Broken Commandment represents a turning point for the animals on the farm, as they are forced to confront the reality of their new society and the hypocrisy of their leaders. By analyzing the symbolism and themes of this chapter, we can gain a deeper understanding of the characters and their motivations.

As you continue your exploration of Animal Farm, we encourage you to keep an open mind and consider the many ways in which the story reflects the complexities and contradictions of human nature. Thank you for visiting our blog, and we look forward to hearing your thoughts and insights on this timeless work of literature.

People Also Ask about Analyzing the Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5:

  1. What is the Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5?
  2. The Broken Commandment in Animal Farm Chapter 5 is No animal shall drink alcohol.

  3. Why is the Broken Commandment significant to the story?
  4. The Broken Commandment is significant to the story because it shows how the pigs, who are the ruling class, are starting to become corrupt and act like humans. It also highlights the hypocrisy of the pigs, who created the commandments in the first place to promote equality among all animals.

  5. How does the Broken Commandment affect the other animals on the farm?
  6. The Broken Commandment affects the other animals on the farm because they start to lose faith in the principles of Animalism, which they believed would bring them a better life. They see the pigs as becoming more and more like humans, and this makes them question whether the revolution was worth it.

  7. What does the Broken Commandment reveal about the pigs’ leadership?
  8. The Broken Commandment reveals that the pigs’ leadership is becoming more totalitarian and less concerned with the well-being of all animals. The pigs are willing to break their own rules if it benefits them, and this shows that they are not interested in creating a truly equal society.

  9. What is the significance of the pigs’ decision to change the commandments?
  10. The pigs’ decision to change the commandments is significant because it shows how they are manipulating the other animals for their own gain. By changing the commandments, the pigs can justify their actions and maintain their power over the other animals.

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *